PPLI for New York Residents: What Changes When the Family Lives in New York

Suppose a family on the Upper East Side sold its company in 2024 and now keeps $20 million with two hedge fund managers and a private credit fund. The managers do their job. So do the tax returns. Most of what those strategies earn is short-term gain or ordinary income, and for a New York City resident at this income level the marginal bite in 2026 is 37% federal, 3.8% net investment income tax, 10.3% New York State and 3.876% New York City. That is 54.976 cents of every dollar. Because the family's state and city taxes run far past the federal deduction cap, almost none of it comes back on the federal return.

At some point the family's CPA, or a private banker, mentions private placement life insurance. The idea is familiar: the same managers run the same strategies inside the separate account of a variable life policy, and the growth is not reported as income while the policy stays in force. What PPLI is and the federal tax conditions are explained elsewhere on this site. This guide takes a narrower question: what changes in the decision when the family lives in New York?

Five things. Three tax returns instead of one. A short list of carriers allowed to sell the policy, and a rule about where the paperwork is signed. A state estate tax that begins at $7.35 million and has a cliff. Trust rules that decide where a trust-owned policy is taxed. And a residency test that follows the family if it ever leaves.

Three tax returns, one policy

New York residents pay state tax on worldwide income, and the state return starts from federal adjusted gross income (Tax Law section 612). Capital gains are taxed as ordinary income; the state has no preferential rate. For 2026 the schedule for a married couple filing jointly reaches 9.65% above $2,155,350 of taxable income, 10.3% above $5,000,000 and 10.9% above $25,000,000 (Tax Law section 601(a)(1)(vii)). A couple with New York adjusted gross income above $25 million loses the lower brackets altogether: a supplemental tax raises the whole taxable income to a flat 10.9% (section 601(d-5)). The statute now carries these top rates through tax years beginning before 2033.

New York City residents add the city's own tax. The top city rate is 3.876%, and it begins at $90,000 of taxable income on a joint return and $50,000 for a single filer (2025 schedule, Form IT-360.1 instructions). For the reader of this article, every marginal dollar carries it.

Marginal rate on short-term gains and ordinary income, 2026	Federal	New York State	New York City	Combined
Joint return, taxable income $5 million to $25 million	37% + 3.8% NIIT	10.3%	3.876%	54.976%
Joint return, New York AGI above $25 million	37% + 3.8% NIIT	10.9% on all taxable income	3.876%	55.576%
Same income, Westchester or Long Island resident	37% + 3.8% NIIT	10.3%	none	51.1%

Who pays is a question of residence, and New York has two ways to catch you. The first is domicile. The second is statutory residency: a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the year, plus 184 days or more in the state (Tax Department definitions). The same test, with the city substituted for the state, decides city residency. A Westchester or Long Island address avoids the 3.876% but not the state rates. A Manhattan apartment kept all year, plus enough nights in it, brings the city tax back even for someone domiciled in Greenwich.

What the policy changes follows from the first sentence of this section. Because the state return starts from the federal figure, income that federal law does not tax is not taxed in Albany or at City Hall either. Gains inside a qualifying policy's separate account are not current income while the contract meets Section 7702, the owner stays clear of investor control and the account meets the 817(h) diversification tests. The death benefit excluded under IRC section 101(a) is excluded on the state return for the same reason. New York does not add a rule here. It adds a number: deferral is worth more at 54.976% than at the 40.8% a Florida resident pays on the same income.

What the policy does not change is the exit. A surrender, a withdrawal above basis, or any distribution from a modified endowment contract is ordinary income in the year received. If the owner is a New York resident in that year, the state and the city tax it at the rates then in force. The policy defers; the owner's residence on the day of the distribution decides who collects.

A hypothetical New York example

This example is hypothetical. The assumptions are stated so that the arithmetic can be checked, and every one of them should be replaced with the family's own numbers and a carrier's actual charge schedule.

A Manhattan couple already has New York taxable income above $5 million, so their marginal rates are 10.3% state and 3.876% city. They allocate $20 million to strategies that return 7% a year, all of it taxed as short-term gain or ordinary income. Federal 37% plus 3.8% net investment income tax brings the combined marginal rate to 54.976%. Their state and local taxes exceed the federal deduction limit many times over, so the example treats the state and city tax as not deductible.

Held directly, $20 million at 7% produces $1,400,000 of income and $769,664 of tax each year. The after-tax return is 3.15%. Inside a policy, the same 7% is reduced by policy charges instead of tax: at all-in charges of 1.0% of cash value a year the net return is 6%, and at 1.5% it is 5.5%.

$20 million, 7% gross, reinvested	After 10 years	After 20 years
Held directly, taxed at 54.976% each year (3.15% net)	$27.3M	$37.2M
Held directly at Florida rates, 40.8% (4.14% net)	$30.0M	$45.1M
Inside the policy, 1.0% annual charges (6.0% net)	$35.8M	$64.1M
Inside the policy, 1.5% annual charges (5.5% net)	$34.2M	$58.4M

The gap is the state and city tax as much as the federal tax. At Florida rates the taxable account compounds at 4.14% rather than 3.15%, and the ten-year difference between a taxable account and a policy shrinks by about $2.7 million. That is the New York premium on deferral, and it is the reason the same policy proposal reads differently in Manhattan and in Palm Beach.

Three entry costs sit outside those curves, and all three depend on decisions covered later in this article:

• New York premium tax at 0.7% on a risk resident in New York: $140,000 on a $20 million premium (Tax Law section 1510(b)(1)).
• Delaware's private-placement rate, which caps the tax at $2,000 a year per policy for a trust-owned single-life policy on a Delaware risk (18 Del. C. section 702(c)(3)).
• The federal 1% excise on premiums paid to a foreign insurer without a Section 953(d) election: $200,000 (IRC section 4371).

The example leaves out what it cannot know: the cost of insurance for these two lives, which depends on age and health; the surrender charges in the early years; the federal itemized-deduction limitation that applies from 2026; the tax due if the policy is ever surrendered; and the pending Senate bill on private placement contracts described on the PPLI overview. It also assumes the policy qualifies under Section 7702 every year. None of this is a projection of any product. You can rerun the taxable side with your own rates in the Portfolio Tax Drag Calculator.

Which carriers may sell the policy, and where you sign

New York regulates insurers more tightly than most states, and the first practical consequence for a PPLI buyer is a shorter list of carriers. Doing an insurance business in New York requires a license from the Department of Financial Services (Insurance Law section 1102), and "doing an insurance business" includes soliciting applications from New York residents and delivering a policy to one (Insurance Law section 1101(b)(1)). Anyone in New York who aids an unlicensed insurer in placing a contract, including a broker, forfeits $500 per transaction on top of the other penalties of the Insurance Law (Insurance Law section 2117). There is no excess-line route for life insurance: the kinds of insurance an excess line broker may place start at paragraph four of section 1113(a), and life is paragraph one (Insurance Law section 2105(a)).

That leaves two ways for a New York family to buy a private placement policy.

A carrier licensed in New York, selling a variable life form approved by DFS. New York's separate-account statute lets a life insurer establish separate accounts for variable life, requires the plan of operation to be approved by the Superintendent, and requires the policy to carry loan, grace, reinstatement and nonforfeiture provisions suited to a variable contract (Insurance Law section 4240(d)(4) and (e)). The insulation of separate-account assets from the insurer's other business applies only "if and to the extent so provided in the applicable agreements" (section 4240(a)(12)), so the policy's own wording matters, and the Department's variable life regulation (11 NYCRR Part 54) governs the form. Some carriers maintain a New York company or a New York-approved form for this reason; the New York product list is shorter, and the investment menu is often narrower than the same carrier offers elsewhere.

A policy from an insurer not licensed in New York, which is lawful only if the contract is "principally negotiated, issued and delivered" outside New York in a state where the insurer is authorized (Insurance Law section 1101(b)(2)(E)). The Department's General Counsel has said in published opinions that New York does not forbid its residents from buying life insurance outside the state, provided there is no solicitation or other contact with the buyer in New York and the later servicing is handled by mail from outside the state (OGC Opinion 04-08-14; OGC Opinion 06-01-06). In practice this is why many New York families sign the application in Wilmington or Sioux Falls, through a trust whose trustee sits there, and why the broker's New York office cannot be the place where the deal is made. The opinions are informal, fact-specific and two decades old; the carrier's own compliance position for New York residents belongs in the file.

The route chosen has three consequences that show up in the numbers.

Premium tax. A life insurer subject to New York's franchise tax pays 0.7% of gross direct premiums "on risks resident in this state" (Tax Law section 1510(b)(1)(iv)), and PPLI carriers pass premium tax through to the policy. Whether a policy on a New York insured owned by a Delaware trust is a New York risk or a Delaware risk is an allocation question the carrier's tax counsel answers, not the buyer; it decides whether the policy pays $140,000 or $2,000 on the $20 million premium in the example above. New York's 3.6% tax on independently procured insurance does not reach a life policy bought out of state, because the tax applies only to the kinds of insurance an excess line broker may place (Tax Law section 1550, cross-referencing Insurance Law section 2105(a)).

Guaranty protection. New York's guaranty corporation covers a resident policyholder of a New York-licensed insurer up to $500,000, and it provides no protection for separate-account values where the policyholder bears the investment risk (DFS, Life Insurance Company Guaranty Corporation of New York). For a PPLI policy the guaranty fund is close to irrelevant in either route, and the questions that matter are the carrier's balance sheet and the separate-account wording, which the Delaware guide and the jurisdictions comparison take up.

The federal excise. A foreign carrier adds the 1% federal excise on each premium unless it has made a Section 953(d) election or has treaty relief with a closing agreement. This is a federal rule and the same for a New Yorker as for anyone else, but it is one more reason the out-of-state route for New York residents usually ends at a domestic carrier rather than an offshore one.

Owner, insured and beneficiary under New York law

The policy's three roles are decided under federal tax law for estate purposes and under New York law for everything else. Three New York rules deserve a place in the decision.

Insurable interest and consent. New York requires an insurable interest when the contract is made, and the written consent of the insured when someone else applies on their life; a spouse may insure the other spouse without it (Insurance Law section 3205). The underwriting side is covered in the PPLI underwriting article. A trust applying on the lives of the grantor and spouse satisfies this routinely, but the application must be built that way from the start.

Creditors. New York's exemption statute protects the proceeds and avails of a life policy, which it defines to include cash surrender and loan values, in favor of a third-party beneficiary against the insured's creditors, and in favor of an owner who insures another life against the insured's creditors; a spouse who owns a policy on the other spouse is also protected against the spouse's own creditors (Insurance Law section 3212(b)). Premiums paid with actual intent to defraud creditors can be recovered from the proceeds with interest (section 3212(e)). The statute is written around who "effected" the policy, so the protection depends on the roles chosen at issue. The asset protection guide has a section on mapping the parties under section 3212; this article does not repeat it.

Divorce. New York is an equitable distribution state, not a community property state, so the spousal-consent mechanics that shape a California policy do not apply here. A policy acquired during the marriage, or funded with marital assets, is generally marital property subject to distribution under the Domestic Relations Law, and its cash value is discoverable. Life insurance in litigation and divorce covers what can be compelled.

The New York estate tax: a $7.35 million exclusion and a cliff

For a New York family with an estate between roughly $7 million and $30 million per spouse, the state estate tax is now often the only estate tax that applies. The federal basic exclusion is $15,000,000 per person in 2026 and indexed after that (IRS, 2026 inflation adjustments). New York's basic exclusion for deaths in 2026 is $7,350,000 (New York State Department of Taxation and Finance). The rate schedule reaches 16% on the taxable estate above $10,100,000 (Tax Law section 952(b)).

The cliff is the part out-of-state advisers miss. The exclusion is not a deduction. It is a credit that phases out once the taxable estate exceeds the exclusion, and "no credit shall be allowed" once the estate exceeds 105% of it (section 952(c)). In 2026 that threshold is $7,717,500. An estate one dollar above it pays New York tax on the entire estate from the first dollar. New York also allows no portability of a deceased spouse's unused exclusion, so each spouse's exclusion is used or lost.

Two more rules tie the estate tax to the policy decision. First, New York's gross estate is the federal gross estate (Tax Law section 954(a)), so a policy the insured owns, or over which the insured holds incidents of ownership, is in the New York estate under the same Section 2042 analysis that puts it in the federal one. Second, New York has no gift tax, but taxable gifts made within three years of death are added back to a resident's gross estate; the add-back applies to deaths before January 1, 2032 (section 954(a)(3)). Gifts made while the decedent was not a New York resident are excluded.

Put together, those rules point the same way the federal rules do, only harder. A policy on the parents' lives that the parents own adds its death benefit to an estate that is probably already over the cliff. A policy owned from issue by an irrevocable trust is outside both the federal and the New York estate, and no three-year rule applies because nothing was transferred. Moving an existing policy into a trust restarts a three-year clock federally under Section 2035, and the New York add-back runs alongside it. The trust mechanics are covered in Irrevocable trusts and PPLI and SLATs and PPLI; the point for New York is that the state estate tax, not the federal one, is usually the number the trust is built around.

A nonresident decedent, by contrast, owes New York estate tax only on real and tangible property located in the state. A life insurance policy is intangible. A family that has established domicile elsewhere therefore takes the policy out of New York's estate tax reach, and the gifts it made after leaving are not added back.

Where the client lives, where the carrier sits, where the trust sits

Three different places answer three different questions, and conflating them is the most common error in New York PPLI proposals.

The client's residence decides which income tax applies to any distribution, which estate tax applies at death, and which insurance law governs the sale. That is the subject of this article.

The carrier's domicile decides the separate-account statute, the guaranty scheme and the regulator. It does not decide the client's tax. A Delaware or Bermuda carrier does not make a New York family's policy a Delaware or Bermuda matter for New York tax purposes, and a New York carrier does not make the policy worse; the jurisdictions comparison sets out the differences.

The trust's situs decides where the trust is taxed and, under the insurance law, where the owner is. New York treats a trust created by a New York domiciliary as a resident trust, taxable on all its income, unless three conditions are all met: every trustee is domiciled outside New York, the entire corpus is located outside New York, and no income or gain is New York source (Tax Law section 605(b)(3)(D)). The statute deems intangible property, which includes securities and a life insurance policy, to be located in New York if any trustee is a New York domiciliary, and the Tax Department has applied the test that way (TSB-A-20(2)I). A Delaware or South Dakota trustee is therefore not a formality; it is what keeps the trust out of New York's fiduciary tax. New York closed the incomplete gift non-grantor trust route in 2014 by including such a trust's income in the grantor's own New York income (Tax Law section 612(b)(41); TSB-M-14(3)I), which is one reason a policy, which produces no current income to the trust while in force, is attractive inside a trust that cannot escape New York any other way.

The trustee's location is also, in most proposals, where the application is negotiated and the policy delivered, which brings the insurance-law route and the premium-tax allocation back to the same office. Whether that office is a New York risk or a Delaware risk for section 1510 is, again, the carrier's determination to make and to put in writing.

If you might leave New York

A sizeable share of the families reading this will not be New York residents in ten years. The policy does not need to change when they go; it was built under federal rules that travel. What changes is the audit.

New York examines a change of domicile closely, and the burden of proving the move is on the taxpayer. The statutory residency test is the second trap: a New York apartment kept as a permanent place of abode for substantially all of the year, plus 184 days or more in the state, makes a Florida domiciliary a New York resident again. The Tax Department's audit guidelines have applied the "substantially all" test as a period exceeding ten months since the 2022 tax year, down from eleven (Hodgson Russ on the 2021 Nonresident Audit Guidelines).

For the policy, three timing points follow. A surrender or MEC distribution taken after the move is taxed where the owner then lives, so a family that expects to leave should not plan an exit from the policy before it leaves. Gifts to the trust made after the move escape the three-year add-back. And a policy that stays in force through the move carries no New York consequence at all, because nothing is reported in the years in between. For a family on the fence, the policy is one of the few assets that is indifferent to the question until the day it pays out.

The trust is less portable than the family. An irrevocable trust created by a New York domiciliary stays a New York resident trust after the grantor moves unless it meets the three-condition test, so the trustee and situs chosen at the start are what carry the trust through a later move.

Six questions to settle before signing

1. Is the carrier licensed in New York, or is the policy being negotiated, issued and delivered outside the state under section 1101(b)(2)(E), and who has confirmed in writing that no part of the sale took place in New York?
2. Which state's premium tax does the carrier allocate to this policy, at what rate, and is the determination in the proposal?
3. Who will own the policy at issue, and is the trustee domiciled outside New York so that the trust can meet the three-condition test?
4. What is the family's New York taxable estate today, and does the $7,350,000 exclusion or the $7,717,500 cliff already apply to each spouse?
5. If the family leaves New York within ten years, which policy decisions should wait until after the move, and which cannot?
6. Under the carrier's charge schedule for these two lives, at what all-in cost does the policy stop beating a taxable account taxed at 54.976%, and does it still win if the family later pays only federal tax?

Frequently asked questions

Does New York tax the growth inside a PPLI policy?

Not while the policy stays in force and qualifies as life insurance under federal law. New York taxable income starts from federal adjusted gross income, so gains that federal law does not treat as current income are not taxed by the state or the city. A surrender, a withdrawal above basis or a distribution from a modified endowment contract is taxable in the year received, and New York taxes it if the owner is a resident in that year.

Can a New York resident buy PPLI from a carrier that is not licensed in New York?

Yes, if the policy is principally negotiated, issued and delivered outside New York in a state where the carrier is authorized, and no solicitation or other contact with the buyer takes place in New York. New York does not forbid its residents from buying outside the state; it forbids unlicensed insurers and their agents from doing business inside it. The carrier's compliance position for New York residents should be in writing.

Does New York have an estate tax, and does life insurance count?

Yes. For deaths in 2026 the basic exclusion is $7,350,000, the top rate is 16% and an estate above $7,717,500 loses the exclusion entirely. The New York gross estate is the federal gross estate, so a policy the insured owns is included; a policy owned from issue by an irrevocable trust is not.

Is the premium taxed in New York?

A New York-licensed life insurer pays 0.7% on premiums for risks resident in New York, and the charge is passed through to the policy. Where the policy is owned by a trust outside New York, the carrier decides which state the risk belongs to for premium-tax purposes. New York's separate 3.6% tax on independently procured insurance does not apply to life insurance.

What happens if the family moves to Florida?

Nothing has to happen to the policy. Income tax on any later distribution follows the owner's residence at the time, the policy becomes intangible property outside New York's estate tax for a nonresident, and gifts made after the move are not added back. The family does have to prove the change of domicile and avoid statutory residency through a New York apartment it keeps.

Does PPLI protect the cash value from creditors in New York?

Insurance Law section 3212 protects proceeds and avails, including cash value, for a third-party beneficiary against the insured's creditors and for an owner against the insured's creditors, with an exception for premiums paid to defraud creditors. The protection depends on who owns, who is insured and who benefits, and it does not defeat a federal tax lien or a divorce court. The asset protection guide covers the statute in detail.

If you want to test these questions against a specific proposal, describe the policy, the owner and the decision in front of you and we will tell you which of the New York rules above it turns on.

---

Sources and authorities

• N.Y. Tax Law section 601 (rate tables through 2032 and the supplemental tax above $25 million); section 605 (resident trusts and the exempt resident trust conditions); section 612 (New York adjusted gross income and incomplete gift non-grantor trusts)
• N.Y. Tax Law section 952 (estate tax rates, basic exclusion and the 105% rule) and section 954 (New York gross estate and the three-year gift add-back)
• N.Y. Tax Law section 1510 (franchise tax on life insurance premiums) and section 1550 (independently procured insurance, definitions)
• New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, estate tax basic exclusion amounts and nonresident rules; income tax definitions of resident, nonresident and New York City resident; Form IT-360.1 instructions (2025), New York City tax rate schedules
• TSB-A-20(2)I, situs of intangible trust property; TSB-M-14(3)I, 2014 trust changes
• N.Y. Insurance Law section 1101 (doing an insurance business and the out-of-state exemption); section 1102; section 2105; section 2117; section 3205; section 3212; section 4240
• 11 NYCRR Part 54, variable life insurance
• NY DFS Office of General Counsel, Opinion 04-08-14 and Opinion 06-01-06, sales to New York residents outside the state; Life Insurance Company Guaranty Corporation of New York
• IRS, tax year 2026 inflation adjustments ($15,000,000 basic exclusion); 26 U.S.C. section 7702 and section 4371
• 18 Del. C. section 702, Delaware premium tax including the private-placement rate
• Thomson Reuters, itemized deductions after the 2025 Act (SALT cap and the 2/37 limitation), secondary source; Hodgson Russ, the 2021 Nonresident Audit Guidelines, secondary source

Editorial standards: figures are taken from the statutes and agency publications listed above as read on October 19, 2026. The worked example uses stated assumptions and is an illustration, not a projection of any product.

This article is general information for New York residents and their advisers and is not tax, legal or investment advice. PPLI is available only to accredited investors and qualified purchasers, and suitability depends on the full circumstances. Speak with a New York tax attorney or CPA before acting.