The overall Butterfield rating is 3.7 out of 5, the average of its four rated booking centres, weighted by the UHNW client ratings each has received. Centre ratings range from 3 to 4 stars. Each booking centre is assessed separately. The legal entity, protections, services and costs can vary by booking centre. Read the full Butterfield review.
Butterfield earns four stars. Remediation of past findings has been verified by the regulator. What a family should weigh: a significant regulatory finding stands on the record in the last ten years. Not yet documented: how the law protects custody assets in this centre and whether external asset managers have a dedicated desk. These points carry no weight until they are documented.
Noam Cohen, Editor, Bank IntelligenceReviewed 6 November 2026, Q4 2026 edition. The rating weighs the public record together with what clients and their advisers tell us in confidence; retail products, branches and apps play no part.
Where Butterfield stands out
Remediation of past findings has been verified by the regulator.
Deposits are covered by a statutory protection scheme.
The custody terms are public and address most of what a family needs to know.
A full range of private banking services is published for this booking unit.
Most fees are published.
What to weigh
A significant regulatory finding stands on the record in the last ten years.
No public policy on third-party payments or retrocessions.
Legal protection of custody assets in this centre is still to be documented here.
Whether independent asset managers are served by a dedicated desk is not published.
The rating expresses the opinion of PPLI.com on the date shown. It is not a statement of fact about the bank, not a credit rating, not a forecast of failure and not investment advice.
The record
Regulatory and legal record
What regulators, prosecutors and courts have decided, recorded against the legal entity they named, with the status, the amounts as published and a link to the original document. Claims and investigations still under way are marked as open.
20213 August 2021
Non-prosecution agreement, assisting US taxpayers to open and maintain undeclared foreign accounts (2001-2013)
The US Attorney for the Southern District of New York announced on 3 August 2021 a non-prosecution agreement under which Butterfield admitted it knew or should have known that certain US taxpayers used its accounts, including accounts held by sham entities, to evade US taxes between 2001 and 2013. Butterfield paid USD 5.6 million (USD 4.896 million forfeiture of fees and USD 704,000 restitution to the IRS), produced about 386 client files and agreed to cooperate for at least three years. The bank's 2025 annual report states the agreement concluded in July 2024.
Butterfield admits to helping its clients conceal their ownership of foreign bank accounts.
Remedial measures implemented in 2013 to stop assisting US taxpayers with tax evasion; production of about 386 client files; cooperation for at least three years; no contest of a related civil forfeiture action.
US Department of Justice, US Attorney's Office SDNY (with IRS-CI)Resolution with admissionTotal payment USD 5.6 million; Forfeiture USD 4.9 million; Restitution USD 0.7 millionAdmission of the factsPrimary source
Clients and standing
Client experience and financial standing
What clients meet at Butterfield, read from complaint registers, ombudsman decisions and court records, independent reporting and what clients and their advisers tell PPLI.com in confidence. Announcements by the bank, awards and marketing material are left out.
UHNW client ratings
4.1 out of 5, based on 7 client ratings for this booking centre.
What clients report
Butterfield & Son Limited. Press coverage in 2025 and 2026 reports no data breach or client-money incident naming the bank, and concerns its planned purchase of CIBC Caribbean and the effect of that deal on its ratings.
Worth raising with the bank
Ask what CET1 ratio the bank expects once the CIBC Caribbean purchase closes, given S&P's negative outlook of June 2026 and its estimate of about 12 per cent at closing.
Ask whether the CIBC Caribbean integration will change the entity, systems or staff that serve your account before and after closing, expected in the first half of 2027.
Financial standing
Credit ratings published by the agencies, dated by the latest agency or bank document that confirms them
Butterfield shareholders approved the share issue for the CIBC Caribbean purchase, with regulatory filings made around 15 July 2026, up to USD 700 million of Tier 2 debt planned and closing expected in the first half of 2027.
S&P revised its outlook on Butterfield's BBB+ rating to negative from stable, expecting CET1 to fall from 27.6 per cent to about 12 per cent when the CIBC Caribbean deal closes and citing integration risk, unrealised securities losses and a riskier loan mix.
Butterfield agreed to buy CIBC's 91.7 per cent interest in CIBC Caribbean, valued at USD 1.794 billion, adding about 2,700 employees in 41 branches and offices across 10 jurisdictions.
KBRA affirmed the bank's A+ deposit and senior unsecured ratings with a stable outlook, citing liquidity, a CET1 ratio of 25.2 per cent and diversified fee income.
What it costs
What Butterfield charges, compared
Butterfield publishes its fees. The figures below are its list prices, read on 6 November 2026 from the document linked at the foot of this section. To compare banks fairly we put every published fee in US dollars at the same indicative rates and apply it to the same reference amounts, then rate each fee against the average of the other banks that publish it. Five stars is the lowest fee, one star the highest. Terms a family actually negotiates are often different, and the bank can change its schedule at any time.
Price level of the published fees7 fees compared with the other banks that publish them
Fee
Butterfield
Other banks
Against the others
Custody and safekeepingeffective rate on USD 25 million
0.25% a year0.32% at USD 10m, 0.22% at USD 50m; stated as a maximum Source
0.30% a yearaverage of 38 other banks
below the average
Equity tradecommission on a USD 250,000 trade, major exchange
Not in the published schedule: discretionary mandate, advisory mandate, currency conversion, account maintenance, closing the account, lombard loan margin.
How the comparison works: USD 25 million booked with the bank: half under a discretionary balanced mandate, half in custody with advice; 24 equity trades of USD 250,000 and 8 bond trades of USD 500,000 a year; 6 currency conversions of USD 1 million; 24 outgoing international transfers. Tiered fees are applied to those amounts tranche by tranche, stated minimums are applied, and amounts are converted at indicative rates of 2026-11-06. Read how we compare fees.
The bank at a glance
Identity, protection and services
Legal identity
Legal nameThe Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited
LEI549300V8RVM0EMTDPF28
LicenceBanking licence: 'is licensed to conduct banking business by the Bermuda Monetary Authority' (bank's legal page) Source
RegulatorBermuda Monetary Authority (BMA)
Legal formLicence holder
OwnerPublicly listed company (NYSE: NTB; BSX: NTB.BH). Source
Ownership
Group parentThe Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited (listed, NYSE (NTB); BSX (NTB.BH)) Source
ControlWidely held; no shareholder with 10% or more Source (31 December 2025)
Ownership is shown as published, with its date. It describes who owns the bank; it does not, by itself, suggest any wrongdoing by the bank or its owners.
Offered at this booking centreOffered by the group, not confirmed hereNot located, which does not mean unavailable Checked on the bank's own pages, 6 November 2026.
Deposit protectionBermuda Deposit Insurance Scheme: BD$25,000 per depositor per member, Bermuda dollar deposits only. Deposits in US dollars or any other currency are excluded, which matters for most international clients.
Moving the portfolio. Use the published transfer terms as a starting point. Ask the bank to flag positions in your portfolio that would require consent, manual handling or a sale, and to quote the charges separately.
Cross-border eligibility. If a settlor, beneficiary or beneficial owner has U.S. ties, ask the named entity to confirm eligibility for your structure and which investment services it can provide.
Exit costs. The fee comparison shows USD 150 per position for a securities transfer. Ask what rate would apply to your mandate and whether the receiving bank or a sub-custodian would charge separately. See published fees.
Your experience
Rate Butterfield
If you bank with Butterfield or advise clients who do, your experience forms part of its PPLI.com rating. Every response is read by the editor and treated in strict confidence.
Before we publish a significant negative finding that is not already public, we give the bank the facts and time to comment, on the same timetable for every bank. Decisions of regulators and courts are shown as they were published. Corrections we verify are published with the date of the change. Write to [email protected] quoting reference BK-BM-BUTTERFIELD-E20A01.
Reviewing this file with us
Families and their advisers read this file before they open an account. It can only be as complete as the documents we can find, and much of what sets a private bank apart, from its custody terms to the way a client team works, is rarely published.
If you represent Butterfield Bermuda, one of our Bank Intelligence analysts can go through the file with you: correct anything that is out of date, add terms and documents that are not yet public, and set out what has improved since our last edition. The review is a paid engagement for the analyst's time and research.
The rating itself stays with our editor and follows what the documents show, so we cannot promise a particular result. When a review changes the file, this page notes that the bank took part, with the date and what was added.
Researched by the PPLI.com research desk from the public sources listed. The rating is our editorial opinion; read how we rate.
Important information. Editorial opinion of PPLI.com on the date shown, based on public information, client experience and editorial judgment. Not a statement of fact, a credit rating or investment, legal, tax or financial advice; verify with the bank and your own advisers before acting. No liability is accepted for reliance on this content. Bank names and logos are used for identification only. Ratings are updated every quarter. This is the Q4 2026 edition, and a rating can change between editions if something material happens. Full disclaimer
Rating signed by Noam Cohen, Editor, Bank IntelligenceReviewed 6 November 2026Methodology 2.4Reference BK-BM-BUTTERFIELD-E20A01